Skip to content
    EdTech & Innovation

    Artificial Intelligence and Medical Professional Identity

    Hejazi et alAdvances in medical education and practice

    Artificial Intelligence and Medical Professional Identity
    In a narrative review examining the intersection of artificial intelligence (AI) and medical professional identity formation, researchers analyzed conceptual, empirical, and theoretical literature spanning peer-reviewed studies, regulatory data, and national survey reports. The authors found that AI impacts professional identity unevenly. Diagnostic, predictive, generative, and emerging autonomous systems most directly affect medical expertise, clinical reasoning, and professional autonomy. Consequently, physicians are transitioning from exclusive holders of specialized domain knowledge toward roles as validators of increasingly accessible, variably trusted information, a shift underscored by observed automation bias and reduced diagnostic performance.
    The review introduces the concept of the formal-functional gap (FFG) to describe the divergence between the formal locus of clinical responsibility—which continues to rest solely with clinicians—and the functional locus of decision-making influence, which is increasingly shared with AI systems. The magnitude of this gap varies according to AI system configuration, specific professional identity components, and practitioner career stage, introducing distinct risks of 'never-skilling' in medical trainees and 'deskilling' among experienced practitioners. In contrast, ethical responsibility, humanistic care, lifelong learning, and professional authority are influenced more indirectly. To address these shifts, the authors recommend that medical education curricula emphasize sustained expertise, clinical reasoning, professional autonomy, AI-interpretive judgment, and human oversight.

    Key Takeaways

    • Artificial intelligence shifts physicians from exclusive possessors of specialized knowledge toward validators of variably trusted information, with evidence of automation bias and reduced diagnostic performance highlighting this transition.
    • The formal-functional gap conceptualizes the divergence where formal clinical responsibility remains entirely with physicians while functional decision-making influence is shared with artificial intelligence, placing trainees at risk of never-skilling and experienced clinicians at risk of deskilling.
    Read the original sourceAdvances in medical education and practice