EdTech & Innovation
Game-based learning yields higher knowledge than role play in nursing trial
AbdAlfatah et alNurse education in practice

A three-arm, parallel-group, posttest-only randomized controlled trial evaluated the efficacy of technology-enhanced learning modalities compared with traditional instruction for high-risk blood transfusion education. The trial randomized 150 third-year undergraduate pediatric nursing students at Assiut University in Egypt equally (1:1:1) into three cohorts: animation-based learning (n = 50), game-based learning (n = 50), or traditional role-play simulation (n = 50). Knowledge acquisition was evaluated using a content-validated, 12-item researcher-developed questionnaire, and student motivation was quantified using an adapted Intrinsic Motivation Inventory.
Post-intervention evaluations identified a statistically significant difference in overall knowledge acquisition across the cohorts (Kruskal-Wallis H = 6.747, p = 0.034, ε² = 0.032). Pairwise comparisons demonstrated that game-based learning achieved significantly higher knowledge scores than traditional role-play simulation (p = 0.037); however, animation-based learning did not achieve a statistically significant difference compared to role-play (p = 0.195).
Student motivation also differed significantly among the three study arms (H = 21.281, p < 0.001, ε² = 0.131). Post hoc analyses revealed that both game-based and animation-based modalities generated significantly greater motivation than traditional role-play simulation, without a significant difference between the two technology-enhanced approaches (p = 0.107). The findings indicate that while both digital interventions enhance learner motivation, only game-based learning produced a measurable knowledge advantage over standard role-play simulation.
Key Takeaways
- Game-based learning yielded significantly higher blood transfusion knowledge scores compared to traditional role-play simulation (p = 0.037), whereas animation-based learning did not show a statistically significant knowledge advantage over role-play (p = 0.195).
- Both game-based and animation-based learning produced significantly higher student motivation than traditional role-play simulation (overall H = 21.281, p < 0.001, ε² = 0.131), with no significant difference in motivation observed between the two digital modalities (p = 0.107).
Read the original sourceNurse education in practice
